|
To print article, click
Print on your browser's File menu. Go back Posted 7/7/2000 ![]() Kenner & Niederhoffer What's next for Wall Street |
Extra! 8 new rules to help you ride the bull It's going to be a long summer for market roughriders, so hold on tight, follow the lessons of history and, in an emergency, don't be afraid to swing a cane. Plus: Keeping score in our contest with insider-trading expert Carr Bettis. By Laurel Kenner and Victor Niederhoffer Some scientific advertisers spend comparatively small sums in advertising. Yet they have made their products as well known as certain advertisers who spend far more. How do they do this? The answer is testing, testing, testing. -- "Tested Advertising Methods," by John Caples Every tested rule in the market held this week.
Kenner & Niederhoffer Victor Niederhoffer has traded stocks, currencies and futures worldwide for the past 40 years; he is the author of "The Education of a Speculator." Laurel Kenner is a trader and former Bloomberg markets editor. In a special series of weekend columns for MoneyCentral, they'll assess the past week's Wall Street performance and next week's prospects. Let us know what you think in the Start Investing Community. Buying after panic declines of this nature leads to substantial gains almost 80% of the time, with the average rise over the past six years coming to about 3% over the five days. The rule was first stated by Henry Clews 113 years ago, in "Twenty-Eight Years in Wall Street": In times of panic, old veterans of the Street hobble down to Wall Street on their canes "to buy good stocks to the extent of their bank balances, which have been permitted to accumulate for just such an emergency." When the panic is over, "these old fellows quickly deposit their profits with their bankers...and retire for another season to the quietude of their splendid homes." When to swing the canes The "take out the canes" rule has held, in spades, since that time except for one horrible period during the Depression.
Going against the trend when stocks break through a round number is almost always good for a profit. The Down 35 stocks that broke from above $200 to below $100 have gone up 57% since we recommended them on May 26. Bullish employment reports mean trouble The only cloud on the horizon as this magnificent week wound to a close was that another tested rule is highly bearish. Over the last several years, bullish employment reports have almost invariably been followed by serious declines. The odds for a decline over the next week are about 4-to-1, with the average move a drop of about 2%. The main difficulty with rules, though, is a lack of testing, and this is particularly true of the stock market. Investing is alone among modern disciplines in being almost entirely innocent of the scientific method. Such was the state of advertising in 1925, when John Caples, considered the greatest ad man ever, started out in the business. In his first week, Caples wrote in "Tested Advertising Methods," he heard many rules from more experienced hands. For example, an artist told him that pen-and-ink drawings are good in furniture ads, while a copywriter said headlines were not needed when short copy is used. "I believed these statements," he wrote. "I believed that these men had a real foundation for what they said. I tried to remember the rules they laid down." But when he went to work in mail order, where each ad was tested and results tabulated, "I quickly learned that much of the talking about advertising I had listened to and believed in was just talk. Too often the speakers were stating opinions they mistook for facts." If only stock market technicians and other rule-givers prone to exhorting without testing would take these words of Caples to heart, the stock market world would be a much gentler, kinder and more profitable place for the average investor, as has the advertising world for small businesses since he published his rules. Follow the insiders The general rules we've listed at the top of this column have been tested and counted with our own computers, our own programs and our own data -- and have been used in practice with varying degrees of success. They work. However, there are no panaceas, particularly in the selection of individual stocks. We are well aware of our own ignorance in that area, but if forced to put our chips on something, it would be this: an investor does better buying stocks that corporate insiders have been buying, and selling those that insiders have been selling. That rule that has been tested over 50 years, with consistent significant practical and statistical profitability, To this end, we first reported on May 5 a group of stocks that fit our tested rules for superior performance based on a combination of large declines and recent insider purchasing. On June 2, we updated our list and reported the wisdom of Carr Bettis, the world's leading expert, in our opinion, on insider trading, who has taken the art of forensic investigation of the subject to a level that is truly beautiful to behold. Bettis takes into account such factors as the absence of buying or selling in situations where one would expect it, the insider's position in the company, their record in purchasing and the intricacies of derivatives trading. We challenged Bettis to a contest: His picks against ours, priced as of June 2, with the contest to end on Dec. 2. The results follow, and we are pleased to report that both are beating the 0.1% gain in the S&P 500. Insider Infighting: Niederhoffer vs. Bettis
We're in the lead so far, 2.9% to 1.9%. He wishes to make six changes in his portfolio, removing all the shorts and one long. However, for the purposes of our contest (in which the loser will eat crow in December, raw, squawking and fully feathered) we are not accepting his changes, as it ain't cricket to change the rules mid-game. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Kenner &
Niederhoffer Recent articles: • After six market months, a climactic equilibrium, 6/30/00 • Perfect storm leaves markets swamped , 6/23/00 • On baseball, strategy and the technology revolution, 6/16/00 more... |
We have tested the eating of crow and it
tastes much better roasted, with the feathers removed, in a little pear
sauce. At the time of publication, Victor Niederhoffer maintained long and short positions in index futures and options. His position changes regularly from net long to net short as the market fluctuates in the short term, but remains highly bullish for all time periods forward. Laurel Kenner owns Dial, Finova, Carpenter, Modis, HB Fuller, Interstate Bakeries, National Commerce, StorageTek, Sykes and Ucar. Mail Laurel and Victor at lkvn@hotmail.com. MSN Money's editorial goal is to provide a forum for personal finance and investment ideas. Our articles, columns, message board posts and other features should not be construed as investment advice, nor does their appearance imply an endorsement by Microsoft of any specific security or trading strategy. An investor's best course of action must be based on individual circumstances. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||